Back to all posts
November 7, 2026

AEO Is the New Snake Oil

AEO Is the New Snake Oil

AEO and GEO, getting ChatGPT and Google's AI to recommend your business, can matter. But the way it's being sold to service businesses is SEO snake oil with a new label: same retainer, same incumbents ahead of you, no stable ranking to measure, and no way to double it overnight the way you can turn up ad spend.

AEO can matter. Same as SEO, good fundamentals are important, and I'll say that once so nobody accuses me of pretending otherwise. AEO is AI engine optimization, or answer engine optimization, or GEO, generative engine optimization, depending on who's sending you the invoice. It means getting ChatGPT, Google's AI answers and Perplexity to mention your business when somebody asks for a roofer. I build AI agents for a living, so this isn't coming from someone who's scared of the robots. But the way AEO is being sold to service businesses right now is the same snake oil I wrote about in SEO Is Snake Oil, with a new label on the bottle.

Here's the blunt version.

Same retainer, new acronym

Watch what happened. AI answers showed up at the top of search, clicks started drying up for a lot of sites, and the SEO industry had a problem. Their product was getting harder to sell. So a lot of the same agencies printed new business cards. Same monthly retainer, same thick report, same "it takes time," except now the chart says "AI visibility" instead of "keyword rankings."

A carnival salesman peeling an SEO label off a snake oil bottle and pressing a fresh AEO label over it
Same bottle. Same price. New label.

And most of what gets a business mentioned by an AI is the same stuff that got it ranked on Google. The models learn from the web and they search the web. They lean on the businesses with years of reviews, press, directory listings, Reddit threads and other sites talking about them. So the AEO game has the same shape as the SEO game. Authority, content, trust, time. Different acronym, same hill.

You're still starting behind

If you're a newcomer, the fifteen-year-old company down the road isn't just ahead of you on Google. It's ahead of you inside the models. It has been mentioned, reviewed, linked and argued about online for fifteen years, and a lot of that was baked in before you opened. You can't pay an agency to retroactively give you a decade of people talking about you.

A young contractor holding one thin flyer at the foot of a towering library of material while a glowing AI orb reads the stacks
The model has fifteen years of reading on the incumbent. It has a flyer on you.

Reviews still help. Get them. But the big player in your market has more, and adds them faster, because they have more customers. Same treadmill, now with a chatbot on it.

There is no page one

Here's the part that makes AEO even better snake oil than SEO: there's nothing solid to measure. With Google, page one was at least a real place. You could search and see where you were. An AI answer is generated fresh every time. Ask the same question twice and you can get a different list.

That's not me guessing. SparkToro and Gumshoe ran a study where about 600 volunteers put the same 12 prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI almost 3,000 times. The odds of getting the same list of brands twice were under 1 in 100. The odds of getting them in the same order were far worse. The researchers concluded that tracking your position in an AI answer is close to meaningless, and the only number worth watching is how often you show up across hundreds of tries.

So when someone sends you a screenshot that says you're number one in ChatGPT, understand what you're looking at. One pull of a slot machine, saved as a PNG.

A contractor pulling the lever of a glowing slot machine whose reels show different AI answer cards
Ask twice, get a different list. Now picture paying a retainer for the lever.

You can't double AEO overnight

Same as SEO, good fundamentals are important. I'm not telling you to skip them. But here's the thing nobody selling AEO wants to say out loud: you can't double it overnight. There's no budget to raise. If you need twice the jobs next month, there's nothing to turn up. You can't call ChatGPT and ask it to recommend you twice as hard in March.

A contractor turning up the dial on a lead machine with one hand while searching a sealed AI orb for a knob that isn't there
One machine has a dial. The other one has a waiting room.

Paid ads can. Need more work? Raise the spend, tune the campaign, and the phone responds within days. Booked solid? Turn it down. That's a dial. AEO, like SEO, like referrals, is a slow build you earn over years, and it moves on its own schedule, not yours. Do the fundamentals so the slow build is working for you. Just don't confuse it with the thing you can actually turn up.

The silent-failure business model

AEO is easy to sell for the same reason SEO was. It's slow, it's hard to measure, and the seller always has an excuse. The models are probabilistic. The algorithm changed. We're building authority. Meanwhile the retainer clears every month. There's already a whole category of dashboards that ask an AI the same question a few hundred times and chart how often your name comes up. That's a useful thing to know. It is not a lead.

A salesman handing a roofer a glossy visibility report while the roofer's phone sits silent on the kitchen table
The visibility chart goes up. The phone stays quiet.

It's also a textbook silent failure. A bad ad campaign screams at you, you can see the cost per lead. A bad AEO retainer quietly does nothing while the invoices clear, and nothing happening looks exactly like "give it time." If someone is charging you thousands a month and can't point to the jobs it produced, you're not buying marketing. You're buying a subscription to hope. Ask for proof, same rule as everywhere else.

Where AEO actually belongs

Treat it like SEO. Hygiene. Baseline. The foundation under the house, not the house. The good news is the hygiene is mostly the same work, done once:

  • A fast, clean site that says plainly what you do, where you do it and how to book, written so a person or a model gets it in one read.
  • Pages that answer the questions customers actually ask you on the phone, in plain language.
  • Correct business info everywhere: Google Business Profile, Apple Maps, Bing, Yelp and the directories in your trade, with the same name, address and phone on all of them.
  • Real reviews, steadily.
  • No accidental lockout. Some hosts and firewall settings now block AI bots by default, so check that your site isn't telling the AI search crawlers to stay out.
Cutaway of a house on a glowing foundation of website, map, review and chat icons, with customers walking in the lit front door
Pour the foundation once, do it right, then build the thing that brings people through the door.

Some of that can be automated now. An AI blogging agent that publishes real, useful posts on a schedule is a legitimate tactic and I use one myself. Useful content is useful whether a person or a model is reading it. But none of it is a guarantee, and none of it is worth a monthly retainer with a new acronym on it.

Then put your money and attention where it reliably comes back: a paid advertising system you can turn up and down, and follow-up that makes sure every lead gets a call, a text and a booked appointment. That's what took Island Cabinets past a million. Nowhere in that story is a keyword, and nowhere in it is a chatbot mention either. Same principle as engineering the consequence instead of relying on discipline: don't hope the leads show up, build the thing that produces them.

The takeaway

AEO can matter. Good fundamentals are important, and they'll matter more as more people ask an AI instead of searching. But it's slow, the incumbents are ahead of you, there's no stable ranking to measure, and you can't double it overnight the way you can turn up ad spend. Do the hygiene. Skip the retainer. Build the machine that actually fills the calendar, and let AEO be the quiet baseline underneath it.

Want the machine instead of the retainer?

Paid ads plus follow-up systems is what we build at HyppoAI. It's what took a cabinet shop past a million.

Let's build it

Want to talk about what you're building?

Get in touch